Dr. Nero wrote:In my own defense, I didn't intend to mention anything about my spiritual experiences. But as soon as Random Stu started questioning my qualifications relative to the subject matter of the Heart, I had no choice but to defend myself by describing my Heart-related spiritual experiences.
In your original post, you used the phrase: "(Heart)-enlightened." It's a phrase that has no commonly-accepted meaning. So my question was, first of all, about why you choose to use jargony speech like "(Heart)-enlightened," rather than plain English. Related to that is the question: what's the value of your making and holding this concept of "(Heart)-enlightened" (regardless of what meaning you're attaching to it)?
It's odd that you should describe this as "questioning your qualifications." It's more like I'm asking you to communicate with some clarity. Perhaps you're anxious to claim to have "qualifications" of some sort, and will use any excuse to proclaim them.
Or perhaps you got this idea that I was "questioning your qualifications" from my asking, "Where do you get these ideas of '(Heart)-enlightened'... are you claiming to have it yourself right now, are you claiming to have memories of it, or are you repeating ideas from a book?" This is a simple and straight-forward informational question; it's certainly relevent to know what you're basing your claims on.
In a subsequent posting, you wrote, "If I do Ramana's Self-enquiry and enquire to whom my thoughts arise, my attention regularly 'falls' into the Heart-root." So when you talk about "Heart," your claims are based on memories of past experiences, yes? After all, you talk about something that's happened "regulary" (in the past), rather than refering to your actual experience now.
"...'falls' into the Heart-root" is still opaque jargon that doesn't communicating any clear meaning. And regardless of what it means in your mind, the question remains about what value, if any, you find in holding this concept connected to your memories of past experience.
For instance... say I had a wonderful meal last year. That experience is long past. If I start talking about it, as if it has great importance, it's legitimate to ask what my intention is. I might have some good reason to go on about the memory of that meal. It requires some explanation, though, to communicate what that reason is.
Stuart
http://stuart-randomthoughts.blogspot.com/